양심적 병역거부 관련 청문회 자료집
|일시| 2005년 10월 19일(수) 14:00~17:00
|장소| 국가인권위원회 11층 배움터 1
|주최| 국가인권위원회
목 차
□ 청문회 개요 ···················································································································· 1
□ 모두 진술 요지 ··············································································································· 7
○ 종교적 병역거부 관련 청문회 진술자료 ······································································· 9
전원규 (병무청 선병국장)
○ 양심적 병역거부 청문회 진술서 요지 ·········································································· 18
이석태 (연대회의 공동집행위원장)
○ 신념에 의한 병역거부 관련 국방부 입장 ····································································· 33
최 운 (국방부 인사국장)
□ 청문 및 진술 ·················································································································· 41
○ 진술인 : 전원규 (병무청 선병국장) ·············································································· 43
○ 진술인 : 이석태 (연대회의 공동집행위원장) ······························································· 45
○ 진술인 : 최 운 (국방부 인사국장) ················································································ 47
○ 진술인 : 홍영일 (양심적 병역거부 수형자 가족모임 공동대표) ································· 49
○ 진술인 : 정창인 (재향군인회 안보연구소 연구위원) ··················································· 51
○ 진술인 : 임태훈 (양심적 병역거부 관련 활동가) ························································· 53
○ 진술인 : 조남현 (자유시민연대 대변인) ······································································· 55
○ 진술인 : 이재승 (국민대 법과대학 교수) ····································································· 57
○ 진술인 : 제성호 (중앙대 법과대학 교수) ····································································· 59
별첨 1. 양심적 병역거부 관련 법률안 ·············································································· 61
○ 임종인 의원 대표발의안 ······························································································· 63
○ 노회찬 의원 대표발의안 ······························································································· 99
별첨 2. 양심적 병역거부 관련 판례 ·················································································· 145
○ 헌법재판소 결정 ············································································································ 147
○ 대법원 판결 ··················································································································· 205
![[보도자료] 이스라엘의 가자지구 집단학살 공조하는 방산포럼 규탄 기자회견](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/IMG_2300-45x45.jpg)
![[공동성명] 집단학살 아트워싱에 반대한다 예술은 폭력을 세탁하는 도구가 될 수 없다 – 서울 퐁피두센터 한화의 개관에 부쳐](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/hanwha-45x45.jpg)
![[성명] 핀란드 병역거부자들의 대체복무 파업을 지지한다](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/계엄과-쿠데타-1-45x45.png)
![[보도자료] 2026 세계군축행동의 날(GDAMS) 공동기자회견: 군비증강의 종착역은 전쟁일뿐](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/photo_2026-04-27_14-03-35-45x45.jpg)

![[평화를 살다] 갓난아기를 안고 뉴스를 본다](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/jigu-45x45.jpg)
![[평화를 읽다] ‘죽은 다음’에도 끝나지 않는 – 『죽은 다음』을 읽고](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/1-45x45.jpg)
![[참가후기] 전쟁 없는 세상을 상상하는 방법, “오 예!!” – 2026 병역거부의날 기념 평화토크 ‘전쟁이 났는데 아무도 전쟁터에 나가지 않는다면?’](https://withoutwar.org/www_wp/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/photo_2026-05-15_19-29-03-45x45.jpg)